Skip to: Main Content / Navigation

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Add This

An 'enhance'ment to tackle today's tele-sampling challenges?



Article ID:
20130726-3
Published:
July 2013
Author:
Lyle Durbin

Article Abstract

ReconMR conducted a self-funded study to explore and measure the efficiency of three distinct telephone samples: enhanced cell phone, random digit dialing cell phone and landline.

Editor's note: Lyle Durbin is CEO of ReconMR, an Austin, Texas, research company. He can be reached at lyle.durbin@reconmr.com or at 877-732-6667. This article appeared in the July 22, 2013, edition of Quirk's e-newsletter.  

 

For quite some time, public opinion researchers have relied heavily on the telephone to reach random, unbiased samples that were projectable to any given population. Initially, this was easily achieved with virtually all households containing a telephone line via a landline that was answered frequently. But with Caller ID and the pervasiveness of cell phones, the landline is no longer the gold standard in gen-pop sampling. 

 

Randomly-generated telephone samples of dedicated wireless numbers can augment a landline study but provide little in the way of accurately targeting smaller geographies and the low efficiency of these samples leads to higher project costs. This has left many researchers struggling to find the appropriate methodology to confidently sample general market populations.

 

Solve the sampling dilemma

 

"Enhanced" U.S. cell phone samples offer the potential to solve the random sampling dilemma. Utilizing the telephone survey center of ReconMR's sister company, CRI, we conducted a self-funded research study to test the efficiency, representation and any potential bias from this new telephone sample. As part of a larger study exploring technology and media usage, 600 total respondents were interviewed across the state of Texas, with 200 surveys completed from each of three distinct telephone samples - enhanced cell phone, RDD cell phone and listed household landline. Scientific Telephone Samples provided all of the telephone numbers. Quotas were imposed to ensure each sample type contained proportionate geographic representation among the four largest Texas metropolitan areas (Austin, Dallas-Fort Worth, Houston and San Antonio). Because the landline sample offers opportunity for multiple household members to qualify for the study, quotas were imposed upon this sample to ensure an even gender distribution. No other quotas were implemented.

 

Very promising

 

The testing provided very promising results. Dramatic efficiency gains were observed with a much higher response rate coupled with fewer non-working numbers. This led to almost half as many telephone numbers required to complete the same number of interviews when utilizing the enhanced cell phone list. Even with the greater cost associated with this type of list, the increased efficiency of the sample leads to total fielding costs that are 20-30 percent lower than landline or RDD cell phone samples.

 

While lower costs are always welcome, they should not come at the sacrifice of proper representation. To examine this, ReconMR compared key demographics achieved from the three sample sources. With regard to age and race, both cell phone samples achieved samples much more proportionate to the general population than the landline sample. While the Census reports 34 percent of the adult population to be under the age of 35, the landline sample only produced 8.5 percent within this age category, while the enhanced cell phone sample achieved 31 percent and the RDD cell phone sample achieved 41 percent. Most importantly, very few differences were noted in both the makeup and attitudes of the enhanced cell phone sample and the RDD cell phone sample. With the disproportionate demographics within the landline sample, many differences were noted between this sample and both cell phone samples.

 

Much more representative  

 

The ultimate goal of any research is to obtain a sample that proportionately represents the entire study universe, providing data that is projectable to the population. While the enhanced cell phone sample provides a representative, cost-effective sample list, it is important to recognize the potential groups that would not be included in this sample. Obviously, there still remains a significant and relevant population that does not have a cell phone.  

 

Additionally, there exists some evidence from the study that respondents with lower income and lower education appear to have a lower likelihood of inclusion within the new enhanced cell phone sample. However, when used in conjunction with the traditional telephone sources, this new sample appears to reach important audiences that, without such a sample, would potentially be left out.

Comment on this article

comments powered by Disqus

Related Glossary Terms

Search for more...

Related Events

6TH CONFERENCE OF THE EUROPEAN SURVEY RESEARCH ASSOCIATION
July 13-17, 2015
ESRA will hold its 6th Conference of the European Survey Research Association on July 13-17 in Reykjavik, Iceland.
SENTIMENT ANALYSIS SYMPOSIUM
July 15-16, 2015
Alta Plana will hold an event, themed 'Sentiment Analysis Symposium,' on July 15-16 at The New York Academy of Sciences in New York.

View more Related Events...

Related Articles

There are 2298 articles in our archive related to this topic. Below are 5 selected at random and available to all users of the site.

6 essential steps for successful global segmentation
This article looks into the challenges faced in developing market segmentations that work both globally and in diverse local markets and explores ways of overcoming these challenges.
From the Publisher April 1988: Research confidentiality a must
Tom Quirk shares an experience when he needed to keep a persistent executive at bay to protect the confidentiality of research and uphold his legal and ethical responsibilities.
Ethnography tracks the migration of technology into the American kitchen
For many Americans, a kitchen is no longer just a place for making meals. The author’s ongoing study has seen it morph into a HIVE, a highly interactive virtual environment that incorporates food preparation along with checking e-mail, surfing the Web and a host of other tech-related activities.
Data Use: Using key driver analysis to guide employee satisfaction research
Employee turnover is a large expense for mass retailers and fast-food firms. By surveying employees, companies can identify and address the factors that drive turnover.
Segmentation tools help predict patient needs
In the health care market, customer relationship management solutions can help providers to be more targeted and efficient in reaching the right patients with the right information to improve wellness, approach disease more proactively, or to lessen the physical and financial burden of chronic illness. This article discusses segmentation tools that help predict patient needs, including the Consumer Healthcare Utilization Index (CHUI), which provides a health risk profile similar to the way a credit rating calculates an individual’s credit risk.

See more articles on this topic

Related Suppliers: Research Companies from the SourceBook

Click on a category below to see firms that specialize in the following areas of research and/or industries

Specialties

Industries

Conduct a detailed search of the entire Researcher SourceBook directory

Related Discussion Topics

TURF excel-based simulator
03/06/2015 by Nicky Turche
TURF excel-based simulator
12/16/2014 by Joseph O. Fayese
Hi Giovanni
10/17/2014 by Dohyun Kim
request
06/06/2014 by Monika Kunkowska
TURF excel-based simulator
04/17/2014 by Giovanni Olivieri

View More